Canada’s Refugee Policy is Under Pressure.
On April 15, 2025, Canada’s refugee policy is back in the spotlight as a surge in asylum seekers at the Quebec border raises concerns.
Fueled by U.S. President Donald Trump’s deportation policies, this increase could reshape Canada’s approach to asylum seekers during a heated federal election.
In this 4,000-word guide, we’ll explore the challenges, political debates, and historical context of Canada’s refugee system, while highlighting the human stories behind the numbers.
Table of Contents
A Growing Crisis at the Quebec Border
1. The Surge in Asylum Seekers
Canada is witnessing a notable rise in asylum seekers crossing into Quebec, particularly at the Saint-Bernard-de-Lacolle border, south of Montreal.
In the first six days of April 2025, the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) reported 557 asylum claims at Lacolle—nearly matching the entire month of January’s total.
This spike follows the Trump administration’s March 2025 decision to revoke temporary legal status for tens of thousands of Venezuelans and Haitians, prompting many to flee north to avoid deportation.
Frantz André, a spokesperson for a Montreal-based group aiding undocumented migrants, noted that many Haitians are crossing after receiving letters from U.S. authorities revoking their status.
Numbers So Far: Despite the recent surge, overall asylum claims in 2025 are down compared to 2024, when airports were a primary entry point.
U.S. Impact: Trump’s policies have driven fears of mass deportations, with over 532,000 migrants potentially losing temporary protected status by April 24, 2025.
2. Political Reactions During the Election
The 2025 federal election, dominated by economic concerns over U.S. tariffs, has seen refugee policy re-emerge as a key issue.
Liberal Leader Mark Carney and Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre have both addressed the surge, reflecting a shift in tone from Canada’s historically welcoming stance.
Mark Carney’s Stance: On April 8, Carney blamed the U.S. for the influx, stating, “It’s not acceptable for the United States to send us all their asylum seekers.”
He suggested leveraging the Canada-U.S. Safe Third Country Agreement (STCA) to return claimants to the U.S.
Pierre Poilievre’s View: Poilievre, speaking in Alberta on the same day, criticized the Liberal government for enabling “bogus” asylum claims, saying, “If they are a fraudster, they will have to go,” while emphasizing support for “real” refugees.
3. Public Sentiment and Media Influence
Public opinion on refugees has shifted, with a 2024 Environics Institute poll showing 43% of Canadians—especially in Ontario and the Prairies—doubting the legitimacy of asylum claims, a 7% rise from the previous year.
Media coverage has played a role, with some outlets using alarming language like “tsunami of illegal migrants” or “border towns bursting at the seams.”
Yvonne Su, director of the Centre for Refugee Studies at York University, criticized such rhetoric as exaggerated and disrespectful, arguing it fuels a backlash against asylum seekers.
The Global Context: A World in Turmoil
Record Displacement Worldwide
By mid-2024, the United Nations reported over 122 million people displaced globally due to conflicts in regions like Ukraine and Gaza—triple Canada’s population.
Of these, nearly seven million were asylum seekers.
Canada approved 46,480 asylum claims in 2024, a 200% increase from 2018, when it led globally in refugee intake.
This global displacement crisis, exacerbated by climate change and geopolitical tensions, continues to drive migration to Canada.
Historical Comparison: In 2017, a surge of asylum seekers crossed at Roxham Road in Quebec following Trump’s first election, a pattern repeating in 2025.
Quebec’s Capacity Concerns: Quebec’s immigration minister has warned that the province is at its limit, echoing concerns from 2023 when Roxham Road saw 39,000 unofficial crossings.
U.S. Deportation Policies Fueling the Surge
Trump’s 2025 deportation crackdown, including a January executive order suspending the U.S. Refugee Admissions Program and plans to deport undocumented immigrants, has heightened fears among migrants.
Community groups in Canada are preparing for a potential influx, with experts like Jennifer Elrick from McGill University predicting a “profound impact” on Canada’s borders.
The STCA, updated in 2023 to cover the entire U.S.-Canada border, allows Canada to turn back asylum seekers unless they have family in Canada or meet other exceptions.
3. Canada’s Historical Openness Under Strain
Canada’s reputation as a refugee haven dates back centuries, from United Empire Loyalists in the 1700s to Vietnamese “boat people” in the 1970s.
A decade ago, then-Prime Minister Justin Trudeau welcomed Syrian refugees at Toronto’s Pearson Airport, a moment symbolizing Canada’s openness.
However, recent trends show strain, with 278,457 pending asylum claims as of early 2025—the highest in decades—and a record 457,285 refugees and claimants.
The Asylum Process: A Complex Journey
1. Navigating Canada’s Refugee System
Canada’s asylum system is a maze of legal and bureaucratic processes, involving multiple entities:
Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC): Sets refugee policies and targets, aiming to welcome 442,500 to 550,000 permanent residents in 2025, with a focus on economic growth and family reunification.
Immigration and Refugee Board (IRB): An independent tribunal that adjudicates asylum claims, ensuring fairness but facing backlogs.
Resettlement Programs: Government-assisted programs and private sponsorships, like the Blended Visa Office-Referred program, help resettle refugees, often prioritizing family reunification.
Nicholas Fraser, a senior research associate at Toronto Metropolitan University, highlighted the challenges: “Imagine if you’re a refugee who doesn’t speak the language… while trying to navigate the process and your psychological trauma.”
2. Legal Rights and Challenges
Canada adheres to the 1951 Refugee Convention, ensuring asylum seekers cannot be deported to dangerous countries while their claims are processed.
However, concerns persist.
Aisling Bondy, president of the Canadian Association of Refugee Lawyers, noted that some failed claimants are deported while appealing risk assessments, potentially sending them back to persecution.
Additionally, family reunification programs are facing scrutiny, with visa denials for couples rising at an “alarming rate,” according to lawyers cited in the original article.
3. Support for Asylum Seekers
Asylum seekers in Canada have rights to healthcare, work permits, and freedom of movement, though they must report address changes to authorities.
Settlement programs, like the Resettlement Assistance Program (RAP), provide income support for up to a year, but not all claimants qualify, particularly those awaiting IRB decisions.
Community groups, such as Bridges not Borders in Hemmingford, Quebec, have historically supported arrivals, offering food, toys, and legal advice at crossings like Roxham Road.
Political and Public Debate: A Divided Nation
Election-Year Tensions
The 2025 election has amplified debates over refugee policy.
Carney’s push to return asylum seekers to the U.S. under the STCA contrasts with Poilievre’s focus on cracking down on “fraudulent” claims, reflecting a broader shift in political rhetoric.
Quebec Premier François Legault has also voiced concerns, previously calling for the STCA’s revision in 2023 due to the province’s strained capacity.
Carney’s Proposal: Returning claimants to the U.S. could reduce pressure on Canada but risks violating international obligations if the U.S. is deemed unsafe.
Poilievre’s Hardline Stance: His focus on “real” refugees may appeal to voters skeptical of asylum claims but could alienate humanitarian advocates.
Public Perception and Backlash
The 2024 Environics poll reflects growing skepticism, fueled by media portrayals and a 2024 surge in asylum claims by international students, which then-minister Marc Miller called an “alarming trend.”
Posts on X reveal frustration, with some users labeling asylum seekers “freeloaders” and questioning why they aren’t sent back to the U.S.
However, experts like Su argue this backlash is an overreaction, emphasizing the need for balanced narratives that respect refugees’ dignity.
Canada’s Deportation Trends
Canada has also ramped up deportations, with 7,300 people removed between January and November 2024, an 8.4% increase from 2023.
About 79% were failed refugee claimants, up from 75% in 2023, reflecting efforts to maintain the asylum system’s integrity.
However, this raises concerns about fairness, as some deportees may face persecution if returned prematurely.
Historical Context: Canada’s Refugee Legacy
1. A Long Tradition of Welcome
Canada’s refugee history spans centuries, starting with United Empire Loyalists fleeing the American Revolution in the 1700s.
The country later welcomed Hungarians and Czechs in the mid-20th century, though racial biases initially limited non-white arrivals.
The 1970s marked a shift, with Canada accepting Asians expelled from Uganda and Vietnamese refugees after the fall of Saigon.
Robert Vineberg, a former Citizenship and Immigration Canada official, noted, “It’s a part of who we are. We’re a generous society.”
2. Refugees Shaping Canada’s Identity
Refugees have enriched Canada’s cultural mosaic, contributing to its reputation as a diverse, inclusive nation.
From Vietnamese communities in Toronto to Syrian entrepreneurs in Vancouver, their stories highlight the positive impact of resettlement.
However, the current surge tests this legacy, as Canada balances humanitarian commitments with practical challenges like housing and integration.
3. Lessons from Past Crises
The 2017 Roxham Road surge, where 39,000 crossed unofficially, prompted Canada to amend the STCA in 2023, closing loopholes and reducing illegal crossings.
Yet, the 2025 surge shows that border closures alone don’t address the root causes of migration.
Experts like Maureen Silcoff argue for opening official ports of entry to allow safe, dignified crossings, rather than forcing migrants into dangerous routes.
Challenges and Future Directions
Capacity and Infrastructure Strains
Quebec’s capacity concerns mirror broader challenges.
Toronto saw hundreds of asylum seekers sleeping on streets in 2023 due to shelter shortages, a situation that could worsen with a 2025 influx.
The CBSA’s plan for a new processing center near the Quebec border aims to manage potential surges, but funding cuts to settlement services—set to decrease in 2025-2027—may hinder integration efforts.
Balancing Humanitarian and Security Needs
Canada must balance its humanitarian obligations with national security.
The IRCC’s 2025-2027 Immigration Levels Plan targets 442,500 to 550,000 permanent residents in 2025, with a focus on economic growth, but plans to reduce overall numbers in 2026 and 2027 to manage population growth.
Proposed policy enhancements include better pre-screening, stronger bilateral agreements with the U.S., and community-based settlement programs to support integration.
The Role of Community Support
Grassroots efforts, like those by Bridges not Borders in Hemmingford, show the power of community support.
From providing essentials at Roxham Road to advocating for STCA abolition, these groups have shaped public discourse and supported legal challenges.
As the U.S. ramps up deportations, Canadian communities must again prepare to assist arrivals, learning from past efforts to ensure safe, dignified support.
A Crossroads for Canada’s Refugee Policy
Canada’s refugee policy faces a critical moment in 2025, as U.S. deportations drive a surge in asylum seekers at the Quebec border.
With the federal election amplifying debates, the next prime minister will need to address global displacement, public skepticism, and systemic challenges while upholding Canada’s humanitarian legacy.
From historical openness to current complexities, this issue touches the heart of Canada’s identity.
Explore how Canada can navigate this crisis with compassion and pragmatism.
Stay updated with CTC News.
