Gavin McKenna was left off the ice for overtime and the shootout Thursday as the Toronto Maple Leafs fell 4-3 to the Los Angeles Kings at Scotiabank Arena.
Head coach Jim Hiller said after the game that the decision was based on the demands of three-on-three overtime and his desire not to place McKenna in a high-leverage situation before he was ready.
Table of Contents
Why Gavin McKenna did not play in overtime
McKenna was available during the game but did not receive a shift during the five-minute overtime period, which ended without a goal.
He also was not among Toronto’s three shootout attempts, with Auston Matthews, William Nylander and Jack Roslovic taking the Leafs’ turns.
“Three-on-three is just a different game in the NHL,” Hiller said, explaining that he does not assess a player’s five-on-five performance in exactly the same way when making overtime decisions.
Hiller added that McKenna had been watched as the coaching staff considered using him, but was ultimately called back to the bench.
“He’ll get out there eventually,” Hiller said, while emphasizing that he wanted to make sure McKenna was prepared for the moment and would not leave the young player feeling responsible if the shift did not go well.
Leafs surrender three-goal lead
The decision came during another difficult night for the Maple Leafs, who lost their eighth consecutive game.
Toronto built a 3-0 lead through goals from Matthews, John Tavares and Dakota Joshua before Los Angeles scored three times in the second period to level the game.
Erik Haula’s goal at 14:51 of the second period completed the comeback, and neither team scored in the third period or overtime.
Adrian Kempe then scored the only goal of the shootout to give the Kings a 4-3 victory.
The result left Toronto with one point from the game but extended its winless run to eight games.
Hiller says McKenna will eventually get the chance
Hiller’s explanation indicates that McKenna’s absence was presented as a situational decision rather than a permanent change in his role.
The coach said the rookie would eventually be used in overtime, but gave no specific timeline for when that would happen.
Three-on-three overtime creates more open ice and places greater emphasis on puck control, one-on-one play and the ability to create scoring chances quickly.
That makes overtime deployment particularly noticeable for a highly skilled young player such as McKenna, especially when the Leafs are searching for a way to end a prolonged losing streak.
Hiller also said the five-on-five game and overtime require different evaluations, suggesting that a player’s regular-shift performance is not the only factor in the decision.
What comes next for Toronto
The Maple Leafs will now have to regroup after surrendering another lead and failing to close out a game in which they had controlled the opening period.
Matthews finished with a goal and an assist, while Nylander recorded two assists as Toronto generated 27 shots on goal.
Anthony Stolarz made his case for consideration after Hiller described his performance as solid, although the coach did not commit to a change in the team’s goaltending rotation.
For McKenna, the immediate question will be how Hiller manages his role in regulation and whether the rookie receives a larger opportunity in a future overtime situation.
The Leafs’ next games will show whether Thursday’s decision remains a one-night choice or becomes part of a broader approach to managing McKenna’s development and late-game responsibilities.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did Gavin McKenna not play in overtime against the Kings?
Jim Hiller said three-on-three overtime is a different situation from five-on-five and that he wanted to make sure McKenna was ready for the high-leverage moment.
Did Gavin McKenna play in the shootout?
No. McKenna did not participate in the shootout, which Los Angeles won 1-0.
What was the final score between the Maple Leafs and Kings?
The Kings defeated the Maple Leafs 4-3 in a shootout on November 19, 2026.
How many games have the Maple Leafs lost in a row?
Toronto’s defeat to Los Angeles was the team’s eighth consecutive loss.
Will Gavin McKenna eventually play in overtime?
Hiller said McKenna will get an overtime opportunity eventually, but he did not provide a specific date.
Fact-Checked: The game result, scoring sequence and Jim Hiller’s explanation were checked against NHL game records and the Maple Leafs’ official post-game media availability.
Disclaimer: Overtime deployment can change from game to game based on coaching decisions, player readiness and game circumstances.