The Supreme Court of Canada is expected to release its decision on Quebec’s Bill 21 on Friday, November 27, bringing a closely watched constitutional challenge to the province’s secularism law to its next stage.
The case could determine whether courts may formally declare that legislation protected by the notwithstanding clause violates Charter rights, even when the law remains in force.
Table of Contents
What the Bill 21 case is about
Bill 21, formally known as Quebec’s Act respecting the laicity of the State, was adopted in 2019.
The law requires people in certain public-sector positions to provide and receive government services with their faces uncovered and restricts the wearing of religious symbols by some officials while exercising their functions.
The restrictions apply to designated authority figures, including teachers, principals, prosecutors, judges, police officers and other public employees covered by the law.
Quebec included a notwithstanding-clause declaration when it adopted Bill 21, stating that the legislation operates despite certain protections in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
That declaration has been renewed and remains central to the legal dispute.
Why the notwithstanding clause matters
The notwithstanding clause is found in section 33 of the Charter.
It allows Parliament or a provincial legislature to declare that a law will operate despite certain fundamental freedoms, legal rights and equality rights protected by the Charter.
The clause does not apply to democratic rights, mobility rights or language rights.
A declaration normally lasts for five years unless it is re-enacted.
Federal Justice Department guidance says section 33 prevents a court from declaring covered legislation invalid because of an inconsistency with the rights listed in the declaration.
The legal question before the Supreme Court is not simply whether Bill 21 is popular or controversial, but how courts should respond when a legislature invokes section 33 before a final ruling on the law’s constitutionality.
What the lower courts decided
The Quebec Superior Court upheld the government’s use of the notwithstanding clause when it considered challenges to Bill 21.
In February 2024, the Quebec Court of Appeal largely maintained that result.
The appeal court concluded that the legislature’s use of section 33 was legally effective under the Supreme Court’s existing interpretation of the clause.
It also rejected arguments that the law violated constitutional principles involving the rule of law and judicial independence.
However, the appeal court found that part of the law affecting minority-language education infringed section 23 of the Canadian Charter.
That finding did not remove the main restrictions from Bill 21 because the notwithstanding-clause issue remains at the centre of the case.
What the Supreme Court could decide
The Supreme Court heard the appeal over four days in March 2026.
The English Montreal School Board, Ichrak Nourel Hak and other appellants argued that courts should be able to issue declaratory rulings about Charter violations even where section 33 prevents immediate invalidation.
Such a declaration would not necessarily suspend the law, but it could provide a formal judicial conclusion that the legislation unjustifiably limits protected rights.
Quebec has defended the broad authority of elected legislatures to invoke the notwithstanding clause.
The federal government and several interveners have urged the court to address the constitutional consequences of using section 33 pre-emptively.
The judges could accept the lower courts’ approach, recognize a role for judicial declarations, or establish a different framework for reviewing laws shielded by the clause.
The decision may also affect future disputes involving provincial legislation that invokes section 33 before courts have completed a full Charter analysis.
What happens before the decision
Bill 21 remains in effect unless the Supreme Court orders otherwise or Quebec changes the legislation.
The court’s decision is expected on November 27, 2026, but the practical impact will depend on the reasons delivered with the judgment.
A ruling focused narrowly on the availability of declaratory judgments could leave the law operating while changing how future constitutional challenges are argued.
A broader ruling on the scope of section 33 could influence governments across Canada that have considered or used the notwithstanding clause.
The case therefore reaches beyond Quebec’s rules on religious symbols and into the balance between legislatures, courts and Charter rights.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Bill 21 in Quebec?
Bill 21 is Quebec’s Act respecting the laicity of the State, which establishes state secularism rules and restricts religious symbols for certain public-sector employees.
When will the Supreme Court rule on Bill 21?
The Supreme Court of Canada is expected to release its decision on Friday, November 27, 2026.
What is the notwithstanding clause?
Section 33 of the Canadian Charter allows Parliament or a provincial legislature to declare that certain laws operate despite specified Charter rights for renewable five-year periods.
Will the Supreme Court ruling automatically cancel Bill 21?
Not necessarily, because the court is considering the legal effect of Quebec’s notwithstanding-clause declaration as well as the underlying Charter claims.
Why is the Bill 21 case important outside Quebec?
The ruling could clarify whether courts may issue declarations about Charter violations in laws protected by section 33, affecting future legislation in other provinces.
Fact-Checked: Key dates, procedural history and the operation of section 33 were checked against the Supreme Court of Canada, Justice Canada and Quebec Court of Appeal records.
Disclaimer: This article describes the pending legal proceedings and is not legal advice.